CWD Control Efforts Divide Hunters, DNR

SharpshooterFacing a shrinking budget and public backlash, the Illinois Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) is considering changes to its current chronic wasting disease control efforts, including the use of sharpshooters to reduce deer numbers. Hunters in northern Illinois couldn't be happier.

"I hunted every day for 11 days straight and never saw a single deer," said Illinois Bowhunters Society Regional Director Jim McFarlane. "It's been terrible."

A lifelong Illinois resident, McFarlane said efforts to control the disease have led to a deep divide and a serious breach of trust between the deer hunting community and the IDNR. He and other hunters wonder why the state has to use hired guns when hunters themselves would be more than willing to step in. Last winter, sharpshooters killed 1,475 deer in the 10 counties known to harbor the disease and nearly 11,000 since control efforts were undertaken in 2003. Up to 28 percent of local deer populations were killed by sharpshooters.

"We want hunters to go in first. If they can't get the job done then let sharpshooters take over," said McFarlane, a 61-year-old engineer from Rockford. "A lot of the sharpshooting efforts are taking place in forest preserves and parks that don't allow hunting. That's their excuse. Why can't they let us in? Someone is going to be killing deer. Our taxpayer money is going to this when we could be doing it for free."


Chronic wasting disease is a fatal neurological disease that was first discovered in captive mule deer in Colorado in 1967 (it's not transmissible to humans). Since then, it's been found in wild and captive deer, elk, and moose in 19 states and two Canadian provinces. CWD was first detected in Wisconsin in February 2002 and was the first known appearance east of the Mississippi River. Eight months later, biologists in Illinois detected it in Winnebago County. Since then, the state has tested about 58,000 deer, with 336 testing positive.


Illinois Department of Natural Resources Director of Resource Conservation Jim Herkert said lower deer numbers are just one of the consequences of trying to control CWD. Along with sharpshooting efforts, the DNR relaxed bag limits, which allowed hunters to take unlimited antlerless deer during the 108-day archery season, among other measures.


"We do know that if we draw back our control efforts, we will see an increase in the prevalence of the disease. That's happened in other states. There is a pretty clear trade-off," Herkert said.

But at what cost, wonders McFarlane. He admits his experience with low deer populations are purely anecdotal and don't reflect the entire northern Illinois hunting community. However, he's heard similar reports from numerous other hunters, particularly those hunting in areas close to the sharpshooting efforts. So has Dave Wiehle, 70, who also lives in northern Illinois. Once supportive of the efforts, he has turned into an outspoken critic of the DNR's efforts, calling the agency's culling efforts "mass murder."

"I have a friend who gave the DNR permission to come onto his land to shoot some deer for sampling. He told them not to shoot bucks because he manages his land for quality deer, but they did anyway," Wiehle said. "The DNR basically destroyed any relationship it had with hunters in this part of the state. The DNR is broke, the state is broke, they raised license fees on us, and now they are using hunter's money to exterminate the deer herd. Deer hunting is big business in this state, and the DNR is doing everything they can to ruin it. They tried the same thing in Wisconsin, and they had to stop it because everybody got so pissed off."


The CWD efforts in Illinois were indeed similar to those in Wisconsin. Soon after the disease was discovered there, the Wisconsin DNR instituted what was known at first as an eradication effort in the region with the highest prevalence. Sharpshooters began shooting every deer they could in an effort to slow the spread of CWD.

"In hindsight, eradication was the wrong term. The public viewed it as an effort to eradicate deer," said WDNR Assistant CWD Coordinator Tim Marien. "We changed it to a control and surveillance effort."

Despite the change, the WDNR ended the sharpshooting program in 2007 due largely to negative public reaction. The hunting community remains suspicious of the WDNR, which hired a public relations company to help smooth out the differences. Things are even more contentious in Illinois. Wiehle said he doesn't know of any hunters who support the DNR's efforts to control the disease. He attended a public meeting held by the DNR last winter that turned into a heated debate between hunters and DNR personnel.


"There were a couple hundred people there. Not one spoke in favor of the DNR or the CWD work, except the DNR employees," he said. "The time to take another look at the CWD program has long passed."

Even non-hunters have had enough.

Last February, Winnebago County officials voted to ban the DNR from any more

sharpshooting efforts within the county. A citizen-led effort to end culling efforts in Dundee Township, however, was defeated 49 to 44 by a popular vote at a township board meeting in April. The board voted last December to allow DNR personnel to shoot 20 deer from a local nature preserve but met strong resistance from hunters and non-hunters soon after the effort started.

McFarlane isn't opposed to efforts to control CWD or even efforts to knock down local deer numbers. However, what bothers him is that there is a clear disconnect between the agency in charge of managing wildlife and the hunting community. Herkert said his agency is planning to survey area residents to get their take on the disease and the efforts to control it by the DNR, something McFarlane said should have happened long ago.

"We don't know how many people are opposed to what we've done in relation to CWD," Herkert said.

What do you think? Should state wildlife agencies enlist the help of sharpshooters to curb the spread of CWD?

Recommended for You

These four hunts will test your endurance. North America Big Game

North America's Toughest Black Bear Hunts

Brad Fitzpatrick

These four hunts will test your endurance.

Check out these top choices for building out your reloading bench. Ammo

Roll Your Own: Best Reloading Supplies

David Draper - April 19, 2019

Check out these top choices for building out your reloading bench.

Hunting in Quebec offers plenty of quality outfitters, affordable hunting options, great fishing and plenty of bears. North America

Bear Hunting Makes Quebec the Ultimate Springtime Destination

Lynn Burkhead - February 01, 2019

Hunting in Quebec offers plenty of quality outfitters, affordable hunting options, great...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

2018 Petersen

2018 Petersen's Hunting Episode 16: Cedar Break Bucks

Kevin Steele treks to the cedar breaks and coulees of north-central Nebraska for a shot at a big prairie whitetail.

2018 Petersen

2018 Petersen's Hunting Episode 13: Forest Buffalo

Craig Boddington returns to Mozambique's fame Coutada 10 for a shot a forest buffalo that's eluded him for 10 years.

2018 Petersen

2018 Petersen's Hunting Episode 12: High Plains Elk

David Draper teams up with Fred Eichler to hunt elk on the high plains of southern Colorado.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

Since the first explorers and pilgrims landed, the inhabitants of this glorious country have been Shooting

7 Favorite Truck Guns

Joseph von Benedikt - May 11, 2015

Since the first explorers and pilgrims landed, the inhabitants of this glorious country have...

A new wave of allergies threatens to turn hunters into vegetarians. News

The Ticks Making Hunters Allergic to Meat

David Hart

A new wave of allergies threatens to turn hunters into vegetarians.

My deer-hunting seeds were planted and nurtured as a youngster on my family's small farm in North America

Best Units for Hunting Western Mule Deer

Josh Dahlke

My deer-hunting seeds were planted and nurtured as a youngster on my family's small farm in

See More Stories

More Whitetail

Craig Boddington encounters a nice young buck while hunting the brushy coulees of central Montana. Whitetail

Central Montana Hidden Whitetails

PHTV Adventures - April 05, 2017

Craig Boddington encounters a nice young buck while hunting the brushy coulees of central...

A good day to hunt whitetails this fall is any day you can get off work. But knowing that some days Whitetail

10 Best Days for Hunting the Rut

Mike Hanback - October 30, 2017

A good day to hunt whitetails this fall is any day you can get off work. But knowing that some...

Digital Editor Emily Kantner traveled to Southwest Texas to chase whitetails and put the new Yamaha side-by-sides to the test. Whitetail

Texas Whitetail Hunting with Yamaha's New Side-By-Sides

Emily Kantner

Digital Editor Emily Kantner traveled to Southwest Texas to chase whitetails and put the new...

See More Whitetail

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save.

Temporary Price Reduction.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.